Recorded Webinar from May 31, 2018
Please join Fitch, Even, Tabin & Flannery LLP for a free webinar, “Advanced Obviousness Analysis: Understanding the Reasonable Expectation of Success Doctrine,” on Thursday, May 31, 2018, at 9:00 am PDT / 10:00 am MDT / 11:00 am CDT / 12 noon EDT.
When an invention combines previously known features, non-obviousness turns on whether the person having ordinary skill in the art would have a reason to make the combination. This analysis requires considering whether the ordinarily skilled person would have a reasonable expectation of success in combining the known features.
Recent Federal Circuit cases provide guidance in successfully arguing for patentability under this doctrine and establish that it applies even when obviousness is asserted based on a single reference. Successfully arguing obviousness in patent prosecution, post-issuance proceedings, and district court litigation depends on this analysis with increasing frequency.
In addition to discussing applicable cases, we will explore these issues:
- When do circumstances favor arguing reasonable expectation of success at the PTAB and during patent examination?
- What types of evidence are helpful or needed to support the arguments?
- How can patents be drafted to establish that skilled persons would not have expected success by modifying the known art?
Our speakers will be Fitch Even attorneys David A. Gosse and Margaret “Peggy” Wojkowski. Dave has a diverse IP law practice with substantial experience in district court litigation and PTAB practice in a variety of post-issuance proceedings, as well as with patent preparation and prosecution. Peggy is a registered patent attorney whose practice currently encompasses patent preparation and prosecution, patent post-issuance proceedings, and product clearance and legal opinions.
A recording of this webinar is available through May 30, 2019.
IP Alert | Federal Circuit Finds Claims Containing Natural Product Are Not Directed to a Judicial ExceptionMarch 20, 2019
On March 15, in Natural Alternatives Int'l. v. Creative Compounds, the Federal Circuit rejected a "law of nature" challenge to claims to a dietary supplement containing a naturally occurring amino acid and a method for treatment of a patient using the dietary supplement. Read more
IP Alert | USPTO Gives Patent Owners New Claim Amendment Options in AIA TrialsMarch 19, 2019
On March 15, the USPTO initiated a new pilot program for motions to amend filed during America Invents Act trial proceedings before the Patent Trial and Appeal Board. Read more