April 23, 2014
Fitch Even Partner Timothy R. Baumann was one of four IP attorneys selected to participate along with five administrative patent judges in a roundtable discussion presented yesterday in Chicago by the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) of the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO). The purpose of the roundtable was to share information about the new American Invents Act (AIA) trials, which include inter partes reviews, post-grant reviews, covered business method reviews, and derivations. The Chicago roundtable was held at the Harold Washington Public Library and was followed by an open reception. Similar programs are being held in seven other cities across the U.S.
The program began with an overview of trials, statistics, and lessons learned, presented by Chief Judge Smith. In addition, a mock conference call was staged, with a patent owner, the petitioner, and a PTAB judge represented. Claim amendments were among the topics discussed during the “call.”
For information on upcoming AIA Trial roundtables and roadshow materials, please visit the USPTO website.
Tim Baumann has extensive experience assisting clients in the acquisition, protection, and management of all forms of intellectual property, particularly through complex patent prosecution and through the preparation of infringement and validity opinions, reexamination proceedings, and patent licensing agreements. Tim also has conducted an IPR proceeding, one of the very first filed.
IP Alert | Knowledge Within the Art Does Not Save Means-Plus-Function Claim Term Lacking Corresponding StructureFebruary 19, 2021
On February 12, in Synchronoss Technologies, Inc. v. Dropbox, Inc., the Federal Circuit affirmed that certain of Synchronoss's claims were invalid for indefiniteness, since the claims included a means-plus-function claim term that did not have adequate structural support in the specification. Read more
IP Alert | Customer Loyalty Program Does Not Claim Patent-Eligible Subject MatterFebruary 16, 2021
On February 8, in cxLoyalty, Inc v. Maritz Holdings, Inc., the Federal Circuit invalidated a patent for failure to claim patentable subject matter, reversing findings of the PTAB relating to substitute claims in a CBM review. Read more